Back to E-mail Index
 
 
 
Subject: lease to own house - can i write off my improvements?

From Jurock.com 'Ask an Expert' at:

 
http://www2.jurock.com/askexpert/ask.asp?aid=121&cid=63

Name TXX XXXXXXX


 My question is: Canadian-specific

 QUESTION:  I have a lease on a BC house (1 year) with an option to
purchase,
 and I've used my own funds to cosmetically improve the property . (1) Can I
 write off these costs some way? (2) Maybe start a home renovation business.
(3) Or
 since this is just a revenue property(I sublet it) is there any way to
claim
 these expenses,that occurred before I purchase the property with the option
 contract.  (4) If I sell the option rights to another party and take my
profit
 without taking possession and what would the tax implication be?  Thx for
 any info

 ---------------------------------------------------------------------------
david ingram replies:

I assume that you are not living in the house so:

1.    If you have "improved" the property to use your own words, the
expenses form part of a capital improvement but are only depreciable (i.e.
subject to capital cost allowance).  You cannot claim depreciation past zero
to create a rental loss.

If you sell the house, the costs would be added to the purchase price and
would then come off the profit.

Under the circumstances you speak of, the tax office would likely tax you as
straight income, rather than as a capital gain because what you have done is
an adventure in trade rather than a long term investment in rental property.

2.    Starting a home renovation business adds to the adventure in trade
part of the answer to number 1.  People who buy houses, fix them up, and
sell them are entitled to deduct expenses but pay tax at double the taxable
income rate of an investor who happens to sell a rental house.  Go to
www.centa.com, click on my income tax guide and then click on capital gains
for a good explanation of the difference.

3.    As above, any improvements made before you buy or before you rent are
added to the adjusted cost base of the property and depreciated rather than
expensed.

4.    As above.  Trading in options is a business, rather than a capital
event.  therefore any profits are taxed at straight rates.  The "advantage"
of trading in options is that if you lose money on the deal, you get to
deduct the loss against other income.  If you lose money in a capital trade,
you can only claim the loss against a future capital gain or carry it back
three years against a past capital gain you have already paid tax on.

We are, of course, available for individual consultations on these and other
real estate and US tax matters.

David Ingram -
www.centa.com
the CEN-TA Group
Real Estate Income Tax Specialists
Mutual Fund Income Tax Specialists
US / Canada / Mexico Income Tax and Working Visa Matters
108-100 Park Royal South
West Vancouver, BC, CANADA
V7T 1A2

(604) 913-9133  Fax (604) 913-9123
Cell (604) 657-8451 10 AM to 10 PM 7 days a week

 







Copyright  © 1996-2008 david Ingram
All rights Reserved